Understanding Car Insurance Valuation
When your vehicle is totaled in an accident, your insurance company issues a payment based on the car’s value. But what determines that value, and is it enough to get you back on the road? This article explains how car insurance companies value vehicles, focusing on the difference between actual cash value (ACV) and replacement cost, and what you can do if the valuation falls short.
Car Insurance Valuation: Cash Value vs. Replacement Cost
The most challenging part of the insurance claim process is accepting the insurer’s assessment of your car’s worth. The estimate often comes in lower than expected, and the amount received may not cover the cost of a similar replacement, or even the remaining balance on the car loan. Most customers are unfamiliar with the methodologies used by insurance companies to value cars.
These valuation methods rely on abstract data that the insurers are careful not to share, making it difficult to challenge a low offer. Understanding the basics of this process can help you negotiate effectively.
Key Takeaways
- A car insurance payout is based on the value of the vehicle before the accident.
- A standard insurance policy doesn’t pay for an equivalent new model.
- It doesn’t guarantee a payment equal to what you may still owe on the car.
- Replacement insurance and gap insurance can bridge those gaps but add to the cost.
Understanding Car Insurance Claims Valuations
When you report an accident, the insurance company sends an adjuster to assess the damage and decide if the car is “totaled.” The company considers a car totaled if the cost to repair it exceeds a specific percentage of its value, typically 51% to 80%, according to Insure.com. Some states, like Alabama, have specific guidelines.
If the vehicle is totaled, the appraiser assigns a value based on what a reasonable cash offer for the car would have been immediately before the accident.
The insurance company then uses a third-party appraiser to estimate the vehicle’s value. This practice helps to minimize any appearance of bias and gives a different valuation methodology. The company considers both appraisals when making an offer.
If you disagree with the valuation, you may be able to hire your own appraiser to counter the insurance company’s appraisal, though this may require your insurer’s approval.
Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement Cost
There’s a major difference between the insurance value and the cost of buying a replacement. The insurance company’s offer is based on actual cash value (ACV). This is the amount someone would reasonably pay for the car, given its:
- Depreciation
- Wear and tear
- Mechanical problems
- Cosmetic blemishes
- Local supply and demand
For instance, State Farm explicitly states that it bases your vehicle’s value on its year, make, model, mileage, overall condition, and main options, minus your deductible and applicable state taxes and fees.
The Depreciation Problem
Depreciation significantly affects the ACV. Simply driving a new car off the lot can reduce its value by 9% to 11%, and decline accelerates to 20% by the end of the first year.
The ACV offer will always be less than the replacement cost, which is the price of a new, comparable vehicle. Unless you add your own funds, your next car will likely be a step down from your old one.
Replacement Cost Insurance
This type of policy considers the total loss the same way but pays for a new car in the same class as your totaled vehicle, at the current market rate. However, the monthly premiums for replacement cost insurance can be significantly higher than for traditional car insurance.
When Valuation Falls Short
The situation can get more complicated if the car is relatively new. The insurance payout may not cover what is owed on the car. If you total a new car soon after buying it, the payout might be less than the remaining loan balance. This is more likely if you used a special financing deal that lowered or eliminated the down payment.
When your insurance check is insufficient to cover the loan, the remainder is the deficiency balance. Because the car is gone, the lender can aggressively pursue the debt through wage garnishment or other means.
The Gap Insurance Solution
Gap insurance covers this issue, ensuring you’re not left with a deficiency balance. It pays the difference between the car’s ACV and what you still owe on the loan
How Do Car Insurance Companies Determine Value?
Car insurance companies assess a number of factors:
- Make and model
- Prior accidents
- Normal wear and tear
- Parts replacements
- Mileage
- Market value
What Is the Difference Between Replacement Cost and Actual Cash Value?
-
Actual Cash Value (ACV): Also known as market value, considers depreciation. It represents what you would receive if you sold the vehicle today. This benefits the insurance company.
-
Replacement cost: Pays for a similar make and model, without considering wear and tear. This is beneficial to the owner.
Can You Ask for More Money When Your Car Is Totaled?
Yes, you can negotiate with the insurance company. Research the ACV of your car and know your state’s total loss threshold, plus any other information to support your case. It’s recommended you research the actual cash value of your car, know your state’s total loss threshold, and any other information that would help your case.
